Discussion about this post

User's avatar
David Truman's avatar

What a superb article, Daniel! Bravo! I teach the history of all the East Slavic lands and, of course, of their relations with neighbours, over well over a thousand years. Like you, I am strongly anticommunist, but post-communist Russia is very different, and has reembraced its cultural roots, including Orthodox Christianity.

I wrote a detailed history of the long and short term events leading to Russia's invasion of Ukraine on my website - see https://freedomandheritage.org.au/russias-invasion-of-ukraine/ and have included some recent updates at the end.

With your permission, I would like to include some quotes from your article on my website, with attribution of course.

The mass Russophobia in most of the West at present, including here in Australia, reflects a calamitous historical illiteracy - they all are reliving, are captives to, the Cold War (as you pointed out in a previous article). The mantra "Ukraine today, Poland and the Baltics tomorrow" is absurd, as anyone who knows history would understand. There are centuries of enmity between Poland and Russia, heavily driven by religious sectarianism between Catholicism and Orthodoxy, the Poles' occupation of the Kremlin in 1610-1612 and disqualification of the Polish candidates for tsar in the Time of Troubles. And from the Polish side, the Poles hugely resented being forcibly incorporated in the Russian empire from the end-18th century partitions of Poland, the Congress of Vienna of 1815, the Polish revolts of the 1830s and 1863, and attempted Russification. Whjy on earth would Putin want to reimport this festering sore?

Likewise, the Baltic states. They hated forced incorporation into the USSR in 1940 and their governments remain implacably anti-Russian.

Putin is on the same page as Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn ("Rebuilding Russia," 1990) : the Balts are not Slavs, and the Poles and not Eastern Slavs.

Expand full comment
Terry's avatar

A fabulous, well thought out and constructed article, Daniel. There are so many highly quotable sentences in there that I shall store it in my "goodies box" and hope that you will allow me to quote you from it in future. Well done!

Expand full comment
33 more comments...

No posts